Real Estate

Infamous mafia don’s former Staten Island mansion lists for $16.8M

This made manse is on the market. 

A baroque bit of local legend is looking for a new owner, one who doesn’t mind this palatial property having some bloody former associates.

In Staten Island’s tony Todt Hill — the highest natural point on the East Coast — a 33,000-square-foot mansion that once belonged to Gambino crime family boss “Big Paul” Castellano has listed for an ambitious $16.8 million, according to social media chatter and the Staten Island Advance

Castellano commissioned the residence — which has eight bedrooms — after he succeeded his brother-in-law, Carlo Gambino, as the syndicate’s don in 1976. 

He designed the opulent property to have a pillared portico and a circular, fountain-equipped drive so it would resemble the White House. Indeed, that’s how it’s known in the neighborhood, The Post reported in 2015 when Hillary Clinton had a fundraiser at the Benedict Road abode. 

The four-story compound was completed in 1980, and the kingpin called it home until his infamous 1985 murder, when John Gotti had him gunned down outside of Manhattan’s Sparks Steak House. 

(“The Boss Is Dead,” read the front page of the next day’s New York Post above an image of his body.)

The home is locally known as “the White House.”
Connie Profaci Real Estate
The front page of The Post on Dec. 17, 1985.
Castellano on July 1, 1975.
Bettmann Archive

With Castellano out of the way, Gotti then took over the family and earned the nickname “Dapper Don” before losing a battle with cancer and dying in prison at age 61 in 2002. 

The Castellano name has, however, continued to appear in the headlines — including in 2013, when Paul’s grandson was arrested for illegal waste carting.

The home last changed hands shortly before then, in 2000, when Selim “Sal” Rusi bought it for $3.1 million.

A look at the grand foyer.
Connie Profaci Real Estate
The property is 33,000 square feet.
Connie Profaci Real Estate
The address has two pools, one indoor and one outside.
Connie Profaci Real Estate
Paul Castellano in New York on July 21, 1959.
AP

Public records now show that the place has a total of three owners and has been extensively redone since Castellano’s time there, according to the Advance. 

In addition to its gangster history, the manse also has a boss-level amount of lavish amenities. 

All those eight bedrooms have an ensuite bath — and an enormous balcony spans the backside of the property.

There’s also a home theater, a gym, a sauna, a “personal beauty parlor,” a wine cellar, a solarium, a library, an elevator, a 13-car showroom, and both indoor and outdoor pools, according to the listing, which is held by Connie Profaci Realty